I will be travelling to St. John in July. This will be my second visit. The first time I stayed in a bed and breakfast which was wonderful, but have decided to rent a villa this time and there will be two couples. I have surfed numerous websites -- need a dependable and honest company. I have seen to many chat forums with people complaining of villas being dirty and in bad repair. Can someone direct me to the reputable ones and recommend villas by name if possible.

Has anyone rented from "Carefree". Looking at villa by name of Plumeria? Anybody stayed at this one? It appears to be low season and numerous villas available.

I am not certain of the areas -- where is Gift Hill?

Any help or advice would be appreciated. Thanks.