I've never been there, but as far as believing what you read on message boards in general - keep in mind everyone is different - we all have different standards, expectations, etc... I will be in St John next week, stating at the Westin. I have read reviews from "don't waste your time" to "the best resort ever". I know the truth is in the middle, and based on what I expect, the stay there will be fine. Don't worry about someone else's bad experience.

thanks scot..for the nice words..i was getting freaked out!!!! My hubby and I are not complainers but..i will say something if things aren't right. How can we not have an awesome time in paradise???mary

Secret Harbor is beautiful. Beach is great, restaurant is great. Don't worry. It's not the Ritz but the beach is much much better and the service is better. The rooms are nice.

thanks so much for those nice words...i just knew i picked a nice place..thanks for the info...mary

A friend of mine who is so picky it borders on obnoxious will ONLY stay at Secret Harbor, if that helps.