The US Virgin Islands Best Guide

Trip Report: Emerald Beach Resort

Notifications
Clear all

Trip Report: Emerald Beach Resort

Please Register / Login to take part in discussions about the Virgin Islands.


14 Posts
3 Users
0 Reactions
1,642 Views
(@Joanna)
Posts: 1
 

This is part one of my trip report..I wanted to get this part posted for the people who told me they are going to Emerald Beach this week. Hope I posted it in time for you..

US & BRITISH VIRGIN ISLANDS TRIP REVIEW – 12/2004

Part 1

GETTING THERE:

Flights found 3 weeks prior to departure through Orbitz.com

Airline used: American Airlines. Tulsa to Dallas, Dallas to Miami, Miami to San Juan, San Juan to St. Thomas. Return legs: St. Thomas to Miami, Miami to Dallas, Dallas to Tulsa.

No notable problems with American until we arrived in San Juan. There was a 3 hour delay with our connecting Eagle flight to St. Thomas. Flight was scheduled to leave at 7:35 p.m. The plane didn’t arrive at San Juan until 9:30. After boarding and all the checks and weight shifting re-arranging that is done on the small Eagle planes, it finally departed San Juan at around 10:30. The AA Eagle touched down roughly (literally bouncing the plane back into the air a couple of times) around 11:15 p.m., over two hours later than the scheduled arrival time, causing us to miss the rental car agent. Picked up the luggage only to find that our daughter’s suitcase was missing. No one knew where it could possibly be. We were told to just fill out the form and if they found it, it would be sent to our hotel. So we took a $15.00 taxi ride 2 blocks to the resort. After trying in vain to find any information out the next day about the suitcase, we resigned ourselves to the fact that it was gone and we would have to replace all of our daughter's clothing for the trip. So, a trip to K-mart and $300 later, we were ready to start the vacation. The missing suitcase showed up 5 days later.

ACCOMODATIONS

Best Western Emerald Beach Resort. Check-in Date: 12/20/2003

This beachfront resort is located literally 2 blocks (3 minutes by Taxi) from the airport.

We checked in at 11:50 p.m. Saturday night. The girl at the check-in desk didn’t acknowledge us until 5 minutes after we walked in the front door. She stood at the desk continuing to total receipts on the calculator. When she finally got around to looking us up on the computer and assigning our room we were too tired to argue about the need for a non-smoking room. We did get a room on the 3rd floor (there are only 3 levels total). All rooms are identical at the Emerald Beach, all with oceanfront, large balconies or patios. Upon entering the room, the first thing we did was check out the air conditioner and the water pressure in the shower because those are two things most often complained about in other reviews. The air seemed to work well (very noisy, but this became a plus because of some airplane noise as well as my husband’s snoring). The water pressure in the shower wasn’t great, but it was adequate..(you’re on vacation!!!). Flushing the toilet, one had to hold the handle down for a count of 5 to get an adequate flush. Once we remembered that, there was no problem.
Now, the smoking room issue. I always try to request non-smoking rooms. We don’t smoke and don’t appreciate going home with all our things smelling like we do. Most hotels say they can’t guarantee a non-smoking room, however, we usually use a medical excuse (I won’t say what here) that usually guarantees us a non-smoking room. Not the case at the Emerald Beach. In order to be moved to a non-smoking room, the manager said we would have to wait until 3:00 the next afternoon and then she only had a room on the second floor. My husband was adament about not losing the 3rd floor room view so we opted to remain in the smoking room. To those who are truly allergic to smoke: BEWARE. These are very smelly rooms. The smoke is not only in all the bedding, etc..it is in the furniture and the ventilation system, so when the air-conditioning comes on, it is like being in a small smoky bar. I would even say that the smoking rooms at the Emerald Beach Resort are WORSE than the smoking rooms in the Vegas hotels. I had to wash everything TWICE once we got home.

The floors are tiled which is good, and bad. They get really sandy and if you’re not careful, they can get really slippery. Housekeeping seemed to do a great job of cleaning them every day however, even sweeping off the balcony. (See additional housekeeping comments below). The rooms are fairly large. They have adequate drawer space. Irons and ironing boards are supposed to come with the room, however, our room did not have an ironing board. One was delivered when I requested it however. There are large in-room safes requiring keyed in codes. We used the safe every day (there is a $1.00 per day charge fee for this) to store my husband’s laptop computer, mini-camcorder, digital camera, several wallets and misc. jewelry. The TV worked fine (satellite so there were a few freeze ups, but who watches TV there anyway?). The internet is dial-up in-room so that did us no good, but if you want the DSL, you have to go to the office at $5.00 for 30 minutes. The bathrooms are small and a bit awkward in their design. If one is sitting on the toilet, they can expect to get smacked into with the door. My husband and I (neither of which is a large person) could not both stand at the vanity at the same time. The shower has a dispenser with Shampoo/Conditioner and a Shower gel. We used neither, since we weren’t sure the last time it had been cleaned out. There were only 3 bath towels, two washcloths and two hand towels that seemed to be standard issue on a daily basis. This was not adequate for our family of 3, especially since we were showering every day. We requested more from housekeeping. The view from the balcony was great. We did have one large tree that partially blocked our view, but we grew to be fond of it since it housed the rooster couple that woke us up every morning as well as it offering a bit of privacy from the beachgoers. The only real complaints of the room would have to be the smoke smell, the vent in the bathroom didn’t work, the water pressure was very low (but I suspect it’s that way throughout the Islands) and two of the lamps didn’t work. Yes, we could have requested new bulbs, but the pace at which things are done on the Islands, it could have been the last day before we received them.

HOUSEKEEPING: Here’s my general take on hotel housekeeping. If one is spending 150 + per night for a room (and that is a modest rate for most hotels), than one should have no problem leaving at least 5 dollars a day for housekeeping. I know that I for one, would not want that job. I can only respect the people who do this for a living. If you want something extra than fork over a couple of extra bucks. When I left a nice tip we got excellent service and even had our tissue box topped with pretty tissue “fans”. The linens were changed daily (I marked them to be sure) and the extra pillows were left on the bed on which they were obviously being used.

HOTEL RESTAURANT/BEACH BAR:

The Palms: This is a typical example of a “hotel” restaurant. The best thing I can say about The Palms? The openness and view of the water was great. The worst thing? Outrageous prices on very limited dinner menu.

A complimentary continental breakfast buffet is served every morning in the restaurant. The same food was offered daily (and I mean, it was possibly LITERALLY the same food offered again and again). The fruit offering was always watermelon. Individual cereal boxes with our choice of Raisin Bran or Frosted flakes (doesn’t matter which one you choose, they’ll both be stale). Yogurt that looked way too lumpy to me (my crazy husband ate it though) and granola bits to sprinkle on top. Orange juice and milk in pitchers. Breads: Various sliced breads (all stale), English muffins you toasted yourself using the commercial type conveyor toaster (people don’t understand the concept of this toaster so only use it if you’re the ONLY one standing there cause other people will handle YOUR muffin). Burned blueberry muffins (I think they were blueberry). Pats of real Butter, no margarine or cream cheese. Do yourself a favor and shell out the money for a real breakfast (away from the hotel) or buy your own breakfast stuff and keep it in your room fridge.

Lunch seemed to be better. We got a couple of Palm Clubs while we were hanging out on the beach. I think we paid 10 bucks each for a sandwich and fries.

Dinner at The Palms: Just don’t do it. The menu is VERY limited and expensive. The food is way overcooked and of course, it took forever for it to be served. We ate dinner there once because it was convenient and we just wanted to try it.

Beach Bar: This is just a tiny tiki hut. No one was there at night. People gathered on Monday night for the free rum punch and wings that are offered to hotel guests. Then it quickly cleared out. The only good thing about the Beach Bar is Sam. He makes a good drink. Tip Sam well...you will only need HALF the drinks you normally would buy, if you know what I mean...

If you are hanging out on the beach or are just too tired to go anywhere offsite to eat (or if you don’t have 3 hours to take a taxi somewhere), trod on down the beach to the hotel next to Emerald Beach, The Beachcomber. They have a GREAT bar and it is more lively at night and the restaurant serves good food too. Avril is a nice, efficient waitress. They decorated the whole hotel nicely with Christmas lights and lighted mechanical deer and they had wreaths on all the room doors.

The BEACH is GREAT! The water was always warm and calm. One could walk out pretty far too without going under! It is perfect for smaller children. The beach seemed to be pretty clean. The chairs are pretty comfy. Get up early and throw your stuff down on a couple to claim them though...no one messed with our towels (heck, I even left a bag with my watch and other things in it). They give you towels at the lobby desk, but bring your own beach towels or do what we did, buy em at K-mart cheap. There were a few cigarette butts in the sand, etc...but I don't blame the hotel for that. I don't understand why smokers think it's perfectly ok to put out their cigarettes in the sand and then just leave them there. We went to Coki beach (more on that in the next part) and Magen's Bay and ended up leaving Magen's Bay because we much preferred the hotel beach. Didn't seem to be many locals there either at our hotel beach, just a few on the weekend. (All beaches in VI are public by law).

A word of warning: If you hate roosters, then think about staying somewhere other than Emerald Beach. There is a couple (we named them Ritchie and Rita Rooster) who live on the beach. They ate potato chips and Funyuns. They hung out in the tree directly in front of our 3rd floor balcony and Ritchie served as our alarm clock every morning. This didn't bother us and it just tickled my daughter, she felt like she had her own personal pet for the week.

Part 2 coming soon...

Joanna

 
Posted : January 6, 2004 4:20 pm
(@hoosier469)
Posts: 96
Estimable Member
 

Good report Joanna.

I'm guessing that every room isn't exactly the same though from your report. In Sept I stayed on the first floor of the building furthest to the right (as you look out to sea). Our bathroom was very large, and had a large vanity that wrapped around two walls. There was also more than enough room from the toilet to the door in my room (about 6 feet).

Funny you mentioned the Rooster and the chicken. My wife named them Fred and Ethel. 🙂 I remember hearing him every day too...which was a nice way to start an early day so I didn't over sleep.

Sam is great at the beach bar, and you are so correct about his powerful drink making abilities. I especially liked his rum and cokes...or more like his rum with a splash of coke for color. 🙂 For some reason when I was there all of the bar seats were taken and a few of the tables. There was a nice little crowd every night.

One thing about the room safes that I didn't really like...you get charged a dollar a day even if you don't use it. I know it's just a dollar, but I don't care for hidden charges for things I didn't even use.

The continental breakfast looks like it was much better during the low season when I was there. Other than just milk and OJ, there was also mango, pineapple, and maybe grapefruit juice. We had a wider selection of fruits and maybe I'm lucky but our blueberry muffins were moist and very good.

Keep the reports coming! I'm sitting here reading this and remembering the great trip I had...and it's currently 5 degrees F here. 🙂

 
Posted : January 6, 2004 8:59 pm
(@patrick)
Posts: 396
Reputable Member
 

Good contrasting reports. That's the beauty of the net and a free country... everyone's entitled to an opinion. Now when we go down to STT we stay at our in-laws. But that won't stop me from saying 'hi' to Sam at the beach bar... if you know what I mean. That also won't stop me from taking my kids to that beach as it seems to be a pretty good one.

You learn something new everyday.

 
Posted : January 6, 2004 9:44 pm
(@Jeff from Texas)
Posts: 1
 

Joanna,
You checked in the day I checked out! I was there from Dec 12-20. Your Emerald Beach review was much like the one I posted. Bottom line is that EBR is an ok place to lay your head down at night for a reasonable price but don't expect too much if your standards are high. I too found the restaurant was to be used more as a means of convenience than one of choice but at least the view was nice.

Your review took me back a couple of weeks. Thanks! The temperature is in the 20's here in Texas and I miss STT/STJ already.

regards,
Jeff

 
Posted : January 6, 2004 10:06 pm
(@Joanna)
Posts: 1
 

Hey Jeff...I went back and read your trip report of Emerald Beach..MY, you caused quite the message board riot!! LOL.

I was wondering what you paid per night for your room. We booked it at 127 a night for 3 nights and then the rates were supposed to go up to 250/night Christmas eve and Christmas night..but when we checked out they never included the increase so we paid the 127 + tax + service fee (which we never did find out what that was for) for all 7 nights. I think you might have scared Gary...I certainly wouldn't stress about staying there if I were you Gary..Especially if you got a good nightly rate like we did. I kind of laughed at the last reply to your post from the lady who was inquiring whether you took your room concerns to management! LOL...that's funny. Management on the Islands...Heehee.

At any rate...my opinions about EBR are sort of moot as our general consensus is to skip St. Thomas entirely in the future. We were much more impressed with the British Virgin Islands and just found out we could have flown to Tortola cheaper!. More on all that in my forthcoming Trip Report Continuations (is that even a word?? LOL).

Later,

Joanna

 
Posted : January 7, 2004 4:07 pm
 Gary
(@Gary)
Posts: 1
 

Yes, there is a little concern here, but we leave in the morning. We've not been on vacation anywhere, so I'm sure it will be great since we don't have anything to compare it to. This is our 10 year anniversary, so I hope it will be great. Not really sure of the rates as it went through a travel agency. Round trip from Fort Smith, Arkansas to STT and 5 nights at Emerald, right at $2500. May be too high, but that was about the price through Orbitz and expedia too. (little higher) I am dis-appointed from reading all the reviews on here about hotels being run down. For the price it cost, I was expecting REALLY, REALLY NICE accomadations. Maybe I should have gone to Hawaii?? We'll see, I'll definately give it a chance before I make a judgement too quick. Gary

 
Posted : January 7, 2004 4:53 pm
(@Joanna)
Posts: 1
 

Gary: Well, if you want to pay 500 a night, you can get REALLY REALLY nice accommodations. Do you all travel much? The reason I ask is because I used to sort of demand that we stay in 4 and 5 star type establisments. The problem is: When all is said and done, it's a ROOM WITH A BED and then you're out of a LOT of cash. Now, if you are planning on spending a lot of time in a hotel room (romantic getaway, etc...) I can understand wanting nice, plush accommodations and a clean hot tub. But, if one is going on a Beach related vacation, whether it be VI or Hawaii, what is really important? Trust me...I am REALLY picky about where I stay. I did a LOT of research before I decided on the Emerald Beach Resort. What was important to us was a clean room with a view (the balcony views are EXCELLENT). You will have a great time and it will all work out fine. Don't worry about the airplanes...they are actually kind of cool, my husband took great photos of a couple of them taking off while he was laying on the beach. Hopefully, the TallShips will still be there when you get there...they were neat to see, especially at Sunset. Definitely check out the TriMaran that is there...they offer snorkeling (and despite what Jeff said) right in that area...my husband snorkeled around the rocks and saw better fish than at Coki...

Get off the plane in STT and just immediately be prepared to SLOW DOWN and relax...you're not going anywhere fast so don't even try. Have a great time and eat at the Banana Tree Grill if you get the chance (it's in Bluebeards Castle on the hill and the view alone is fantastic, but the filet mignon will literally melt on your tongue).

And...tip your housekeeper 5 bucks a day....those people make squat without tips. Be sure to request though that your room get done by Noon. People who didn't request that came back to their rooms at 4 with them still not done.

Joanna

 
Posted : January 7, 2004 6:12 pm
(@Catherine)
Posts: 1
 

Hi Joanna,

I read your report and even if I do not understand all what you mean, I guess that EBR (as Jeff from Texas says) is not the right hotel to go in St Thomas.
I am living in France and I plan a trip to Florida with my husband and our 2 kids next month. I already have got my airline tickets Paris to Miami on Feb the 4, back on Feb the 20th, but nothing else. Last month, I made a round on the net and have discovered USVI. Going from Miami is cheaper than directly from France when you make a "package reservation" by expedia or vacationonline. That is why I decided to book a week in St Thomas.
My first choice was the Beachcomber because of the price. I wrote a little memo on this site asking the best place in St Thomas for kids. Missy, a new islander, answered directly by email and she told me that the Beachcomber seems to be great but a little bit noisy (to close to the airport!).
I see that the EBR problem is also the proximity of the airport plus a lot of disadvantages you have mentionned.
Some people adviced me to reserve at the Sapphire Hotel. OK but when I check the price it seems to be a little bit expensive.
Now, my choice is not done and the time is going. I would like to make a reservation ASAP but I want to be sure of my choice. That is why I am now looking on Ste Croix hotels, they look to be cheaper than in St Thomas.
Has anybody a comment to give me about his stay at the Beachcomber, the Sapphir, maybe another hotel ?
Thanks Joanna for your report, I am anxiously waiting for it.

Catherine.

 
Posted : January 7, 2004 6:50 pm
 Gary
(@Gary)
Posts: 1
 

Thanks Joanna.........I'm leaving the house now. I think everything will be fine too, can't wait to get there.

 
Posted : January 7, 2004 8:49 pm
(@Jeff from Texas)
Posts: 1
 

Joanna,
I'm not quite sure how much I paid per night. The whole package for 8 nights+ R/T airfare for two from D/FW was $2650.

To the rest of the gang, if you got a good rate then don't stress it too much. Yes, there's better but there's probably worse too...

 
Posted : January 7, 2004 9:25 pm
(@patrick)
Posts: 396
Reputable Member
 

Catherine, the airport is not really that noisy. Planes only come and go during the day so you are up and awake then. Hardly any flights at night ... if any. Beachcomber is closer to the airport than EBR but not by much. Sapphire might cost a bit more but it is on the other side of the island. The beach on EBR seems to be great based on posts here so I will be taking my family there next time.

When we travel, all we need is a decent place to sleep. We learned a long time ago that all the extra amenities of higher priced places are not needed as we are out during the day exploring and only come back at night to sleep. We rarely eat the hotel's restaurant (pricey) but instead opt for some local flavor. That's how we found Victor's New Hideaway in sub base.

So as a whole, match the place to stay to your specific needs. And remember you will not be using all the amenities you are paying for one way or the other.

Good luck!

 
Posted : January 8, 2004 12:26 am
(@Joanna)
Posts: 1
 

What part(s) of my report did you not understand Catherine? I'd be happy to clarify them.
You can click on my name and then email me if you want.

Joanna

 
Posted : January 8, 2004 9:52 am
(@Catherine)
Posts: 1
 

Thanks a lot Patrick for your positive answer. You are right, what we need as a family is somewhere to put our suitcases, a clean bathroom and clean beds, that's it !
The view, the sun, the sea, the beach, Sam at his bar, roosters...all that would create an atmosphere I am looking for + being in an American Island: what a good luck !
You know, there are a lot of islands in the carabbean area. Some of them are French as I am (Guadeloupe, Martinique), others are attached to UK or Netherland, some are independants...I don't care, I want to be in an american world because for me it means total and guenuine freedom...and that is what I am looking for too.
I think I am going to make my reservation at the EBR...

 
Posted : January 9, 2004 4:37 pm
(@Catherine)
Posts: 1
 

Joanna,

I read your report a second time and now I think I understand everything. Thanks for your offer of helping me.
Just one question: do you regret having done a reservation at EBR or not ?
Pls reply yes ou no, nothing else.

 
Posted : January 9, 2004 4:41 pm

St. Thomas Activities

Set sail on top-rated charters, explore underwater wonders with scuba diving, encounter exotic animals, and venture into the wild with kayaking and ecotours. Feel the adrenaline with parasailing, aerial tours, and water sports for a memorable vacation.
Book Your St. Thomas Adventure Now
Virgin Islands Books & Maps