Trisel is one of the best sailed vessels doing daysails in STJ - he really does an excellent job handling the boat, which is also really a fast sailing trimaran - leaves from a mooring at the Westin beach - no one else offers the 'around STJ sail' - highly recommend you give him a try - and report back too!

Just booked it!!! Thank you so much for the feedback! (tu)
I am also thinking of booking a trip to BVI on Stormy - http://www.bestofusvi.com/bvi/stormy.html with them as well.
I am hearing a lot of good reviews about New Horizons on the forum as well, but I think that tour is a bit rushed, despite the fact that it makes more stops. Did you hear of these two? What's your preference?
-Julie

New Horizon has a dinner Sunset sail that originates out of Redhook with a stop in St John for picking up people there. We have done it twice and have enjoyed it both times.