Cheryl - we stayed at Island Time on the east end of STX this past April and thoroughly enjoyed the villa and the location. Here's a link to my review, with pictures:

https://www.vinow.com/wwwtalk/read.php?4,102237

For villa rentals, I would recommend Vacation St. Croix, an on-island villa management company. www.vacationstcroix.com. I also toured a number of villas while I was there so if I can be of any help, post or PM me. If you check for my overly long 6 part trip report :D, I included pictures of the villas I toured in a couple of the segments.

not sure if you are looking for a condo or home...we have a 3 bdrm. condo, east end at coakley Bay. Website is rentavilladirect.com, go to St. Croix, then 3 bdrm villa, then Banana Winds. There are also a lot of other villas to check out. good luck..
Leenie

Thanks. 3 bed too big. 2 is good. Will check out rentavilladirect

Sunnybeach-- I sent you a pm.

Hi,
I've been away and just read your reply/post. Even though ours is a 3 bdrm. we only charge by the amount of people staying there.

I think that's the norm, isn't it? I know Donna Ford does that. We're a couple, but always get the three bedroom condo for the price of a couple. Nice to have extra room to spread out the suitcases,etc. I love the view from Coakley Bay, especially the upper condos!

I stayed at Hotel on the Cay, a timeshare and LOVED i!! It was nice to be in town and have a "beach" right there. The price was good too. I loved taking the little boat home everynight.

Thanks everyone for all your help & suggestions on where to stay for our 2 week vacation on St. Croix this fall.Can't wait!
MargyZ came through for us with an awesome villa on the east end of the island. Amonoka. It looks & sounds like our kind of place.
Now the real planning can start!
Still waiting on the airfare to hopefully come down a bit. $1,069.00 for 2 as of 7/21/09

Hi Sunnybeach,

We will be staying at Amonoka next week (also by recommendation...Thanx, MargyZ) and will post how everything goes. It does look and sounds awesome!

Hope you guys heading to Amonoka all have a great time! I think you will will really like Amonoka - maybe some of the fruit trees on the property will be in bloom while you are there, too. I am so jealous - we have nothing planned until spring of next year. I am going to think of you enjoying that lanai and the view out over Buck Island. Hope you both post trip reports with some pix.

Sunnybeach: Airfare is nuts right now - I have been watching it for next spring and ORD to STX is running about $750 pp r/t - hope it comes down soon for you, too. I have it on YAPTA so they send me periodic e-mails of what the airfare is doing and the news has not been too good.

Have a great time, all!

Hey Sunny,
I sent you a PM.