I don't know about anyone else, but there is just something about StJ that makes everything about it romantic for me!!! Eating dinner at Asolare at sunset is pretty cool though, just be sure to make reservations!! Have fun...

Where are you staying? For us, the MOST remantic spot is sunset from whichever villa we rent - like being in your own world and a small slice of dreaming that it really was all yours all the time. 🙂

For beaches, we like Jumbie but really any of hte smaller beaches when few people are there. Perfect for your own private swim and then a nice meal on the beach.

Guess we are kind of simple that way. There are certainly lots of restaurants with great views,etc but really the most romantic melas we've had have been something fromt he gourmet deli or Uncle Joes BarBQue at the villa.

Beyond the "usual suspects" for romatic restaurants like Asolare (which is beautiful), we also like the outside dining at the Westin which I don't hear mentioned often. After sunset, the candlelight and breezes when sitting outside are beautiful.
They often have nice music as well.
Not as expensive as some other places.

-aj

If you are into a little hike...the point a Ram's Head is very special to me. That is where my fiance proposed!! Very beautiful spot!