Please Register / Login to take part in discussions about the Virgin Islands.
Who makes the best take-out pizza on STT?
Pizza Amore in Havensite -chef Johnny B.
Our two favorites (so far)...Ainsley's Beachside Cafe at the Elysian Beach Resort and Island Time Pub at American Yacht Harbor.
Without a doubt ....the Pie Whole in Frenchtown!
Ainsley's and Pizza Amore.
Pie hole has great wood fired pizza, Pizza amore has great pizza with the works, and Island time has wonderful grease pizza!
Island Time Pub has the best Buffalo chicken pizza !!
I love the pizza at Magens Bay! One ginormous greasy pepperoni pizza please!
In this order,
Pie Whole
Pizza Amore
Island Time
Jay
Thanks for the great suggestions. It looks like we could eat a different pizza every day of our trip. Pie Whole looks like a popular choice and I love a wood fired oven and their quirky name. Thanks for your help