Where are you staying?
We stayed at Sapphire Beach & there is a 'point' that goes out into the water from the pool area that is perfect at sunset!! Very romantic! We re-newed our wedding vows there last month. I even set up my video camera on a chair to record it.

Hello Michael,

Banana Tree Grill for dinner... after dinner you can walk out by the pool, there is a nice view, and ask there.

Blue Moon Cafe - nice dinner, then take a walk on the beach, sit in a hammock and then ask.

All the best!!

--Islander

My friend did it kind of cool: He had the ring in his pocket when they were snorkeling and he lifted his head and said to his girlfiend, "Hey! Did you see that?!?" And, of course she said, "What?" So he said, "I'll show you." and then he grabbed the ring out of his pocket ad hid it in his hand. Then, while she was looking underwater at him, he swam doan a few feet and made like he was picking something up from under a rock and then he swam up to her, and, after she got done being amazed at the find, he handed it to her and proposed. Kinda cool, I thought. Another one buried the ring box in the sand under his towel while she wasn't looking and he kept complaining about the sand being uncomfortable. Finally he acte like he could stand it no more, pulled up his towel and started diging, then, after the amazement of the find, he asked her. That was kinda neat, too.

If you go to Paradise Point and walk up a little from the shops, there is a nice gazebo with a great view that would be very romantic during sunset.

http://paradisepointtramway.com/ and click on "Weddings"

The Banana Tree Grill is on the Bluebeard's Castle property. There is a nice view but it is right by the resort pool and hot tub. Might not be to private unless you don't mind.