At least it is not allowed on St John and here is the link to the National Park Rules - just scroll down to the section that addresses metal detecting. Sorry I can't help you if you are visiting STT or STX as I am not familiar with the "rules" on those islands.

http://www.nps.gov/archive/viis/rules.htm

Bummer, my husband will be disappointed. He has metal detected at beaches all over the world (he found a couples wedding ring while they were honeymooning for them) but since we have kids hasn't been able to metal detect. (8 years) This is our first vacation without our kids and he was looking forward it.

On STT he might be able to get away with it on some of the secluded beaches (ones where there are no hotels or resorts), but accessing them will be difficult for a vistor. And then, if someone sees him find something, they will claim that it is theirs and demand that he give it to them. Being secluded, he wouldn't have anyone to look to for help in an instance like that. At Magens Beach for examplle, there is even a sign informing all of the rules, and it is not allowed there, either. He might be wise to just leave it at home, as the effort required to access the beaches where he will not be seen doing it will be more tiresome that the enjoyment he receives from detecting, I suspect. JMHO, of course.

Pia is not quite correct...

Detecting is always allowed but you must use a particular method rather than relying on electronic assistance. It requires one to gradually work their toes into the sand feeling the way while dreaming about the treasures to be found. This 'technique' can be mastered while walking or reclining and works better while looking around hearing the water, wind, etc. rather than listening for beeps.

One of two things occur; you find what you are looking for or you redfine what you're looking for 🙂

Nicely put, Chris!!

Welcome back

Thanks for the information it was an idea to have something to do than just sit and read like my wife does. I've found it's a great icebreaker and people are curious about the machine. The average discussion with a total stranger last around 10-15 min. talking about the interesting and unique finds buried in the sands.It's important to ask and know the rules including the safety on the beach.I guess I'll find some other type of activity maybe snorkeling or combing the beach with binoculars looking for interesting and unique finds on top of the beach. That's a Hobie that everyone can enjoy.

Thanks, Chris! I really missed being away. Who woulda thought you could become addicted to a message board?!? Haha!

Can someone help me, I am on a cruise and Ilost my ring and need to rent a underwater metal detector... how can I in St Thomas - does anyone have any information.

Bob
You can use them at any beach but Magens and St John. I have 2 above ground and an underwater. Have never been kick a hotel beach. Many hotels call me to find lost rings.

The owner of the Pirate's Chest at Paradise Point is an avid underwater treasure hunter and has the eqipment you need. I dunno if he'll rent it to you, but he may search for it for youo. Call Sean at 340-774-5279.

At Hotel on the Cay on St Croix, they welcome my metal detector. I return their lost silverware buried in the sand after the Tuesday night BBQ. Great conversation piece and have heard others have been called to look for lost rings and such on the beach. I usually look like the pied piper with kids following me all over. Very fun but mine isn't too easy to pack.

I can find your ring for you. I do this all the time for people on St. Thomas. I may have all ready found it. Let me know what it looks like and I'll check my rings. If I dont have it I'll go look for it if you let me know where you lost it. Greg