Thanks for all of your help with the villa search. I've narrowed it down to a few (considering). They all look great, but for those of you who know the island please point out if there's something you think would be good to know...
Little Plantation (www.littleplantation.com)
Cielo Vista (carefreegetaways.com)
Wanderer (beachnutsvacations.com) (GCB & Choc Hole)
Caneel Trailside Cottage (vivavacations.com) (Caneel Trail)
Thanks so much for your help. I booked our flights today and can't wait!