First and foremost, St John correct otherwise you are on the wrong forum. St. Johns is on another island altogether.

Trunk Bay would be my bet if you wish to do an oceanside proposal, otherwise rent a car with vistas of the Caribbean sea and the Atlantic Ocean and wait for the right moment. Another thought would be to hire a captian to drop you on a remote beach for the day and then pop the question. Best wishes and I hope that the answer is an astounding "yes".

Molly

to me, anywhere you want to be is perfect.

think about the things you like to do together on the island, particularly something that she enjoys doing, and tie that in. it would make for a non-traditional proposal.

My apologies, it is St. John 🙂
Oh wow, I love the idea of having a captain drop us off on a remote beach for the day bit. Hmmm. Thank you Molly 🙂 Good suggestion.

Thank you Ms. Davis- I will take that one into consideration as well.

you are welcome jayluv, and have an awesome visit!!!

i like the way you took the "st. john" in stride, it's a bit of a pet peeve (even of mine, but i've just stopped noting it because it is so common)... but as you handled yourself here with such aplomb, i have no doubt the your lady is lucky indeed!