Coconut Swizzler at Skinny's. Equal parts coconut rum, 7, Club soda and a splash of Rose's lime. Not too sweet, just enough, and cool and refreshing!

Thats like asking folks whats the favorite flavor of ice cream. As many answers as there are drinkers!!

It makes it fun to read them and see how many we can try when we go.

Mango coladas at Green House. 1 part island Oasis Mango, 2 parts Island oasis colada mix and 1 part rum. Blend into a slushy.

Which island? We may have different favorites on different islands... 😉

If you are asking what the most popular drinks are : IMO
Rum and coke
Heineken
Vodka Cran
Gin and coconut water
Cognac and coke
white wine spritzer
Baileys and coffee

Specialty drinks with umbrellas and/or blended are tasty and popular with the tourists but [except for Painkillers and Bushwackers] each bar usually has their own creation.

Sorry folks, but the famous Bushwacker is the number 1 island drink! All others can be bought elsewhere...only the VI has a standard Bushwacker!

Coconut Rum
Kaluah
Vodka
Ammoretto
Bailey's Irish Cream
(all equal parts - blended with ice)

Mmmmmm...!!!!!!!!!!!

Aaaaah, hands down, Kelly's Passion at the beach bar at the Elysian Resort....Island fruit punch PLUS 151 rum...OMG !

St John Brewers

Their homemade rootbeer with cruzin vanilla rum. This was our favorite the last time in St John.

The only rootbeer that comes close at home is the IBC rootbeer in the glass bottle.

Make mine a mojito! In a real glass (not plastic) with fresh mint.

My favorite is the BBC...it's Bailey's, Rum, Coco Lopez, and banana blended with ice. The best ones I have are at the beach bar at Caneel.

I've heard lots of people RAVE about the BBC. Supposedly the bar in Palm Passage makes some good ones, too. The ingredients sound good, but I'm not a big fan of those frosty, icy drinks. I'll have to try one, though, just to satisfy my curiosity.

Painkiller at Skinny Legs on St.John.
dark Meyers or dark Goslingers rum, pineapple and orange juice, and coco lopez.

For me, a Dark & Stormy (Gosling's Black Seal Rum & Ginger Beer ), Presidente & Red Stripe for beer, & the occasional pain killer. 😀

which island? We are visiting St Thomas

Kelly's Passion at the beach bar Will definitely try this one--we are staying at the Elysian.

we're coming to st j in just a few weeks...I like cruzin rum on the rocks for sipping,,later I move to my all time fav,Chardonay,,an occasional pain killer is good too "beach bar our fav"..,,but honestly, I love anything on STJ.....

I have to say of the selections of drinks on the islands my favorite has to be the Painkiller, at the Soggy Dollar Bar on Jost Van Dyke. My second favorite are the milk shakes at the Udder Delight up the hill near Megan's beach on Rt.35.

Hands down the Bushwacker at Magens Beach....drink it standing in the water !!