We always use and recommend Dependable Car Rental. It is a small family operation and they always go out of their way to be helpful and friendly even when I screwed up setting up my car rental with them until 3 days before we were leaving for St. Thomas. Check out their site at http://www.dependablecar.com/ and tell them that Rick and Deb Manseau sent you. Don't know if it will save you money but it makes you feel like one of the "family". They were recommended to us and we have recommended them to many people who have had nothing but good experiences with them.

Can you rent a car at St. Thomas and take it to St. John