They get decent reviews and are located just a minute from the airport. I'm not sure what their procedure is - whether they pick you up at the airport and take you to their place or whether they bring the car to you at the airport. Just give them a call and ask. Their number is 340-774-0111 or 1-800-800-3665.

Avoid L & L Jeep Rentals at all cost. They have horrible customer service skills and even worse communication skills when it comes to dealing with prospective customers. Stick with Avis, we have used them 3 years running, and have found them to be consistently reliable.

They pick you up at airport, 1 couple at a time, while everyone else waits their turn and then you get in line to fill out paperwork, get the car out of their tiny lot. Last time I had guests rent from them, between the pick up at airport and them getting the car, it took about 2 hrs. Not ideal.

We used Discount on STT this spring and had a positive experience.

We also used Discount last month on the front end and back end of our week on Tortola. Everything went well except when we came back from Tortola. They knew approximately when we would be arriving at the ferry terminal in CA. I called them after we cleared customs and it took them 45 minutes to pick us up. Their office is 2-3 minutes away from the dock. Talk about island time!

At the STT airport teminal, they have AVIS, Budget, Hertz. There may be one more but memory fails me.

The majority of my guests use Budget and Dependable Car (not located at airport but they pick you up at airport and drop you back off at end of rental period. Very good service.)