Ronnie's Pizza
Cruz Bay Pizza
Cafe Roma
Donkey Dinner

Anything ringing a bell?

I believe it was Ronnie's Good for carryout? Right? Better than the Italian rest?

I have to beg the question of why you would even ask about the best pizza on STJ or, for that matter, anywhere in the USVI or the Caribbean in general?

Do you have a problem sampling local delicacies? Are you scared of trying new foods? The restaurants in the USVI are incredibly diverse.

Quite possibly the same reason people like a hamburger, or a taco, or fish and chips?
Some people like to what they like. Why do we need to judge food choices?

I like Cafe Roma pizza, personally.

Ronnie's does a lot of carry out, kind of the typical "greasy pizza' kind of pizza. They are located in the Boulon Center, just around the corner from Dolphin Market.

Cruz Bay Pizza has been around a little while now too. They have had several 'changes' since they first open. I went in there recently for a slice and thought that it was pretty good. Much better than before the changes. Less greasy and they offer a whole wheat crust if you like that sort of thing. They are located in Wharfside Village right by Joe's Rum Hut. Parking can be a challenge though.

No problem eating local fare........just wanted a pizza........I have been to STT at least 30 times and to STJ at least 10 times.......I do enjoy all types of food. Thanks for your comment........Maybe see you in STT...Sometimes we stay on Skyline Dr.

STT Resident wrote:
I have to beg the question of why you would even ask about the best pizza on STJ or, for that matter, anywhere in the USVI or the Caribbean in general?

Do you have a problem sampling local delicacies? Are you scared of trying new foods? The restaurants in the USVI are incredibly diverse.

Maybe because this is a forum where people ask other people about the US Virgin Islands?

I like Ronnies. Never tried the Donkey Diner for pizza yet.