Check the Caneel Bay buffets - I was under the impression they are all-u-can-eat - I was last at their famous Sunday Brunch quite a few years ago so it may have changed since then.

Caneel bay has a buffet, it is quite expensive but VERY good. I seem to remember it was around $45.

St John is not a buffet kind of island. The Caneel buffett is high end and not something that you walk into in your bathing suit but something you dress for and enjoy.

Thanks so much. That sounds like fun dressing up for a buffet. Anyone know a website or what would be on the buffet? Im more than happy to research it further. If it's kinda expensive that maybe just 1 trip there would do it.

There is also a breakfast/lunch buffet at the Westin that kind of sits right by the beach. It has been a few years since I've been but I think it was around $18 per person. Have done both the Caneel Bay buffet and Westin and preferred the Westin of the two. If you go, just walk to the pool and keep going towards the beach and you will see and outdoor/open air seating area to your left.

Great, thanks so much. Maybe I will call or see if there website has the buffet information.

The Westin does have a breakfast buffet, it is $24 per person. And this past Saturday, when I was there, they had a buffet at dinner, it was $36 per person. I had both of them on a recent stay and they were pretty good. It's hard for me to spend that kind of money on a buffet when I can't eat that much, but it is reasonable for a huge eater.